West german webbing ww1 ww2 reddit. Here's a picture depicting those changes.
West german webbing ww1 ww2 reddit. Once the allies were able to spin up their recruitment and training and especially manufacturing, it was pretty much over for the Wehrmacht. After WW1, Germany was forced to pay huge amounts to the victorious nations. Hi guys! I'm just getting into WW2 history and I wanted to know a few things. first of all, ww1 probably would have gone on much longer with how bad the ww1 peace deal was for the central powers, it's easy to forget that it actually wasn't a total victory like ww2 was, it was an armistice, What happened to the average German soldier following the conclusion of WW2? I recently finished the new Netflix docuseries, “Hitler and the Nazis: Evil on Trial. I found no real explanation on the web, I hope I get the answer here. As much as we in the West would sometimes like to forget, the Soviet Union bore the brunt of German aggression. Bonaparte, N. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Then attacked France right before modern weapons arrived. 3. Germany was a pioneer of the idea of combined arms, which is the concept of using mechanized units (mainly massed tanks) in concert with infantry and air power to overwhelm the opponent with speed and weight of force. Unfortunately for Britain, American held it's WW1 debt and refused. Stalin could Maybe I wasn’t paying too much attention in high school, especially during any post-WW2 discussions, but it seems like we went from WW2 to the Cold War. Also, for accuracy, blacken your leather, get a bayonet frog, and fill your bread bag with something. The SN-42 and similar steel cuirass designs were, broadly, protective against fragmentation and submachine gun fire at combat distances. But what happened to all the Nazi and Hitler followers after their fall? How did Germany pick itself up after the war? It seems like Germany went from following Hitler to trying to forget him and his ways. Upon their defeat, East Prussia was given to the Soviet Union (now Kaliningrad) and West Prussia remained in Polish hands. They had their bombers. Say something like Kaiserreich happens, or something more realistic, what would have happened through the 20th century and how would ww2 go down? Before that Allied strategic bombing did create some level of distractions, especially in terms of air force and AA that Germany had to keep in the West, and of course there was some level of drain into Afrika, but it didn't really became important until Normandy landing and German preparations for them. It is a member of Rommel's W rttemberg Mountain Battaillon in October 1916. Also I know that Japan's economy was boosted after pearl harbor due to the west help, but I don't We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Upon losing World War 1, Germany had lost West Prussia to Poland, one of the primary reasons Hitler invaded Poland in the first place was to retake West Prussia- particularly Danzig. S. The belt closes with the buckle via a hook that isn’t secured or closed in any way, and one brisk simple movement of the belt buckle to the left and the belt comes undone. How did they go from losing WW1, economy collapsing, then losing another World War, to then become one of the world's biggest economies? i know how it rose from WW1 but after ww2 how did the world allow it to rise again ? werent they afraid they would bring another war as well? it… I am interested in German history, I would like to know whether a surrendering treaty is imposed on it after WW2 that is still in action today, much like the Versailles treaty from WW1. Can’t find an example with the crossed anchors online, but pretty safe to say it’s ww1 German navy. ) Was the war inevitable? Yes, because it was the centerpiece of Hitler's ideology: According to Blut und Boden (Blood and Soild), the Aryans had to expand to the east in order to save their race from inevitable doom. How true is that? Did they have a chance at all? But the majority of the German air force and navy were in the West and combatting the bombing campaign sucked up a substantial amount of German resources and planning, not to mention the impact of bombing itself. Jul 18, 2014 · Hello to you all. This is a VERY generalized answer and leaves a lot of important details out. And WW2 Cavalry/Luftwaffe y-straps are near identical to the WW1 pattern. Given the size of the German military during WW2, the vast majority were conscripts, since they received their call-up notices soon after turning 18. High quality images of maps. Then you also have the fact that German officers of the generation that fought WW2 were still mad about having surrendered in WW1. In the years 1945-1950, Germany was starting to recover from the destruction caused by WW2. The US created strong armed forces out of a token force during WW1 and WW2, as did Germany in the 1930s. Additionally, many scenes and events were recreated. I wanted to know how they would've fared if they focused on only one side. Ditch the gas mask bag, or fill it with spare MP magazines. It was fascinating to see the difference between both sides of the Wall. Europe: 50 (+6) countries, 230 languages, 746M people… 1 subreddit. Did WW1 and WW2 infantry soldier wear any sort of body armor? Archived post. First of all we need to understand that unlike WW1 who was a major clash from the beginning until the end WW2 was a series of smaller and bigger campaigns against individual countries until Germany's invasion of the Soviet Union. The US had given aid and money to rebuild Europe and Germany after wwW, but given that Germany was supposed to be denazified, were there citizens that still had sympathy towards the Nazi party in Germany? And if so what did the allies plan to do to stop it? The Soviets didn't allow German nationalists - only communist ideologues. The fact that German military industries were scaled back significantly after WW1 is one of those major successes of the Treaty of Versailles that few people talk about. Since we know that the Germans made attempts, this begs the question of what if the allies One big factor is that Germany was a militarist dictatorship while many of its victims weren't (well the Soviet Union kinda was, but again, pants down) and had been getting ready for war, while the others basically were forced to react. If they focus on Russia and stay defensive in the west they could easily defeat Russia by late 1915/early 1916. 46% of the 1939 male population was either dead or seriously wounded. 2. ” It was eye opening. For example, in 1946, East Prussia was erased and given to Poland and the USSR, (its German population forced to move west into the new Germany Hitler in the last days of the war was issuing execution orders and stripping people of their rank for trying to surrender. Did the Wehrmacht have inferior footwear throughout the world wars? Why did Germany struggle much more with the invasion of France during WW1 Because those are three different situations, so there are three separate outcomes. A lot depends on how. Was the war winnable? Not really. A brief overview of Cold War era Bundeswehr webbing types. So, Germany used a similar plan to that of WW1. In 1939, far more practical, external suspenders were introduced, Koppeltragegestell für Infanterie" . France,Benelux and Denmark) that enabled Germany to do better food wise in WW2. Reply reply more repliesMore repliesMore replies Official_Cyprusball • Literally the best AH scenario of all time Reply reply More replies ArcticTemper • This will be a long read, so TLDR: the Allies decide to punish Germany more harshly after WW2. 4M subscribers in the europe community. WWII Y-straps At the beginning of WWII, German troops supported their field equipment via a system of aluminum belt hooks attached to canvas suspenders that were worn inside their tunics. 6. Last week I watched 1917 which obviously takes place during the great war. Instead WW1 would turn into a war of attrition that Germany had no hopes of winning. They only got released after Stalin’s death and rehabilitated in the 60s. When Germany invaded the Soviet Union, the Volga German Republic was abolished and most ethnic Germans in the Soviet Union were deported to Gulags in Siberia and Kazakhstan where they were enslaved for forced labor under harsh conditions, many died. Britain won't be in the war because Belgium wasn't invaded yet. Then Germany would have enough resources to wage a war to the west. The reason why Germany was easily accepted back into the community of nations after ww2 compared to how they were treated after ww1 is because the world had changed during WW2. This was quite similar to what the idea was in WW1. If the Schlieffen Plan succeeds, France probably doesn't exit the war, but Germany is step up very well for a victory in the West in 1916, followed by defeat of the Russians in 1917, with the British subsequently coming to the negotiating table. WW2 tanks were better in just about every respect. But what if they didn’t? Even in our timeline the Germans tried to negotiate a conditional surrender, even though it was impossible due to the allies commitment to the total destruction of nazi Germany. Taking into account that all of them are Hollywood-type movies with no need to be historically accurate, could the germans be considered However, the German High Command failed to also exploit this major breakthrough, and ultimately US troops would eventually arrive in time to join the Allied Summer Counteroffensive of 1918. It's not cut out. In this video we take a look at a typical loadout of the west German army soldier in the early 1960s. United States could have defeated any country with their army and their unlimited supplies and resources, and that includes Russia, that also includes the German army at its highest point. Then Germany attacked right when it knew the allies were not prepared. S if they manage during the last moments of WW2 in our reality, or fail? Should be using the black webbing set by historia. However, well knowing they had allowed the iron curtain a foothold farther west than they had wished, allowing the West German view was a handy way of letting the border to go unrecognized by proxy. By 1915, the webbing was painted from brown to black. Well they’d take parts of west France and Belgium (there is a iron rich region there but I can’t remember the name) most of Eastern Europe would have became part of the German empire, Wilhelm would really have been known as Wilhelm the great and Germany would become the economic and political power of the world. 58 votes, 62 comments. Germany was split up after WWII. In WWI, the Germans knew they had to advance with the utmost speed, every army had to carry out its function to the letter, and everything had to go well in order to fight a successful rapid war of manoeuvre and win the war quickly. If they were like the West then they could be trusted. This Webbing and Uniform would be considered post World War II known as the Cold War . Basically Germany got extremely lucky in WW2 because strategically it was extremely fucked once the US entered the picture. And yet the overall majority either participated in atrocities or simply looked the other way. The year is 1945 and the Axis powers lie defeated. But in short, Just like after WW1 and 2, Germany was forced to be like the West due to conditions put upon them. During world war 2 Germany was able to fight multiple allies on both fronts. Therefore, the legitimacy of both East and West Germany was rather shaky at the time and it was not entirely out of question that an eventual successor state to Did the allies just dismantle and melt everything down or did they take and use the former German weapons? When I look at pictures of military arms of west and east Germany they all look like Russian or American equipment. Fast forward through ww2 where you saw Japan capture Indochina (Vietnam) from the french. Had the German leadership stayed consistent to the Schlieffen Plan and not exposed gaps to the French they would likely have captured Paris, which would have been their greatest chance of winning WW1. May 27, 2024 · English: The German military webbing rig system comprises a belt and Y-strap harness (German: Koppeltragegestell aus Leder mit Hilfstrageriemen) specifically designed for carrying field gear and other equipment. So when Britain went to war against Germany, their once first rate Navy was now decades obsolete. Tanks had also improved massively - WW1 tanks were unreliable and broke down and were uninhabitable for long periods. Depending on how history would turn out however, it was entirely open how the separation (and continued occupation) of Germany would eventually be concluded. World War Supply is Veteran owned & operated! We have been collecting & dealing in historically accurate, quality reproduction militaria for over 20 years. What happened to all the Germans living in those areas? Original West German Bundeswehr issue OD flight coverall as used by Bw flight crews and ground personnel. I've often heard the myth about German troops at the end of WW2 continuing to fight Soviet battalions in order to reach the Western Allies lines to surrender. That made me recalled another film set in WWI 'Wonder woman' where Germans are portrayed as bad guys (as it were WWII). In ww2, the allies took the position that Germany must unconditionally surrender at the end of ww2. My parents were young teens during that time. I believe this to be so because the Germans and the Soviets would want to exact revenge on the allied powers of World War One, such as; The US, England, France, Japan, and Italy; for their disrespect of both German and Soviet sovereignty and colonial territories. The losses were horrendous - something like 20-25MM Soviet citizens died during the struggle including at least 10MM military deaths. In the end, the Americans provided over 10 Billion dollars in foreign capital to the German government, greater than/equal to the Marshall Plan funds provided to West Germany (adjusted for 1948 dollars)! From 1924 to 1929, Germany enjoyed immense prosperity, and economic growth levels returned to or were returning to pre-war levels. Certainly for Europeans, WW1 seems to loom large. Then a global depression occurred and all this led to Hitler gaining power. During World War II, the personal combat items (Kampfausrüstung) included essential items such as: Mess tin (Essgeschirr) World War 1 WW1 and World War 2 WWII collectable webbing items including full webbing sets, belts, straps and accessories. Before WW2, the dead of WW1 were considered heroes, also by the nazis of course, because soldiers have to be heroes and dying for your country is an honor, right? 339 votes, 116 comments. As a result, more states are created and additional land cessions made to Germany’s neighbors, resulting in an overall weaker and more fragmented German region. Given the condition, would say it’s a repop, so who knows. The Man in the High Castle is a show about what would be if Japan and Germany took over. Map of Proposed Boundaries of Germany after WW2, including the actual border changes and occupation zone borders. Large chunks of Eastern Germany were annexed by Poland and Russia. As seen with the What change (s) near the end of WW1 could have prevented WW2? A drawn out war that continues into 1919 with Allied forces along the Rhine river? A harsher Treaty of Versailles on Germany? A greater commitment on behalf of the U. 1 wearing a combination of leather and canvas webbing. They A good example for didactics after WW2 is Jorn Rusen's, The Didactics of History in West Germany. Most pictures I've seen of the No. After WWII Germany was dismembered (it also lost some territory after WWI, but Germany retained most of its "German" areas). Multiple pockets with zipper closure, hook and loop cuffs, leg cargo pockets and patch attachment points. This outcome tries to showcase a mix of both. I visited Germany, including West and East Berlin in 1986. The history of the area was awe-inspiring. But when you think about it, Germany and her allies were: Surrounded by the French to the west, and the Russian Empire to the East. inability to pay these amounts led to huge economic downfall in Germany Which in turn, resulted in the rise of the Nazi's. Danke in advance The compensations paid by Germany after World War 1 ended rarely had anything to do with history. I can see why you'd choose that helmet over historia's Stahlhelm. After World War II, Germany was given loans from the west to be paid back, on top of being forced to pay reparations for crimes of war and pay the salaries of American troops for their own occupation. The population of Germany took a major hit. Would the leather webbing still be used in WW2? I can't find a photo of a No. I grew up in a conservative Christina family in the USA where we talked about WWII. WW1 was called the War to end all Wars for a reason. In december 1970, West Germany finally accepted the border at the Treaty of Warsaw. Today, China has embarked on a program of rapid armament, and many dismiss it for lack of legacy and combat experience. In the early years of the war, this was a fairly new and unfamiliar style of warfare, and the allied forces were mostly unprepared for it (they had noticed the success of German Germany lost 13% of it's European territory after WW1, and roughly 25% of its territory after WW2 which largely make up modern day Poland and Kaliningrad. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 3M subscribers in the MapPorn community. The episodes utilise interviews with historians and so on, which is great but the length of each speaking segment is very limited. The rest of Germany was split into two countries, East Germany and West Germany, and remained split until German reunification in 1990. For discussion of all things World War II. Not only did they lose the two World Wars, they were directly responsible for the evilest person to ever govern in this part of the world. Because very little of Germany was actually occupied at the end of WW1, German nationalists convinced themselves that they didn’t actually lose the war, but were instead defeated by internal traitors (ie Jews). Thats not the same as being "forgotten". How effective were German Marschstiefel in WWI and WWII? The jackboot hasn’t got any laces, and if you’ve been on a hike you know how important it is to lace up your boots snugly. The Soviet controlled eastern Germany would include Prussia, Silesia and the areas the Soviets controlled in the original timeline. It's popular to say that after WWII, Germany was treated "better" than they were after WWI. WW2 is a different story. Now, that's what I'm sceptical about. Reply reply Double anchors indicates navy (kriegsmarine), the flag itself is just a version of the German imperial flag. Did this webbing design start with WW1 or was it used PRIOR to WW1? The hook system seems to have been used in WW1 As was the Carl Jun 3, 2011 · The Osprey book about WW1 "Armies in the Balkans" shows a plate of another German specialist wearing Y-straps. During world war 2 as well they were considered the most advance compared to others. For Americans, it definitely has a lower profile than WW2, I think simply because our involvement in WW1 came very late and was on a much smaller scale than WW2. Brandt knew he was only able to speak for West Germany as it existed in 1970. While I agree that America entering Germany after Pearl Harbor was the most likely outcome whether or not Germany officially declared war, if Germany distanced themselves from Pearl Harbor and severed ties with Japan right away, there's a tiny chance America would have avoided entering the European theater. Poland would still be created, as discussed in Yalta, together with all other countries that were under influence of the Soviet, they would just A German Empire who won the east in WW1 and allied with the new Kingdom of Finland (was the plan before Germany lost WW1) and the Republic of Armenia basically cripples the USSR. I know the most about Denmark on this subject. And, obviously, germans are portrayed as the enemy in the film. The Eastern Front was the real cauldron of World War II. "Historical connections" rarely was an argument for these territorial changes. WW1 debt and WW2 debt are 2 totaly different things. It didn't quite happen until it was clear Hitler's authority was broken. I was just looking at a beautiful doughboy display on USMF I noticed that the doughboy webbing is basically the same as was worn by the USGI of WW2. The main achievement of the Nazi regime was defeating a France that was over eager to surrender, and effectively wiping out most of the Soviet army early on. Someone preaching that Germany should be restored to greatness and should look to the east for new lands would be quickly killed. There were experiments with body armor during World War II (and even some during WW1), most famously including the Russian SN-42 steel engineer's breastplate. What went according to the plan: the US joined at the end of 1941 and had prepared. Plausible sure I mean the area was Majority German and today is still very populated by Germans despite mass deportation and genocide post WW2 however the Russians' insistence on taking eastern Poland to protect Minsk forced them to give Poland certain land concessions in order to keep the Polish happy. I’m currently building a WW2 German webbing kit for some guns I’ve bought, and during my build I’ve noticed something. Another argument was that it actually became weaker as it expanded due to streched supply lines and resistance movements all over conquered areas. If Germany wins in 1918 with the Spring Offensive, we'd get a similar result, with France knocked out, with Britain and then the While the IRL end of WW1 saw the ideal to rearrange borders more closely along ethnic lines rather than imperial control, the outcome of WW2 was pure East/West power politics. This led to hyper inflation and political instability. Also, the headgear looks like an M35. Would Germany and Japan manage to conquer the U. In the West, West Germany was occupied by the Allies, who kept a close watch on things. What if Germany and Austria remained unified after WW2, but under Allied occupation as in our timeline? How the common people from Germany reacted to their defeat in WW2? How they dealt with the fact that their worldview and beliefs of racial superiority were smashed by their new reality as losers of the WW2? I read somewhere that Nazis actually had no chance due to a large difference in economic power between Germany and USA plus allies. Close off one border (France) and invade Russia iirc. The German population was now close to the number it had been at the turn if the century. Britain not being in the war could cause naval battles between France and Germany which The breakdown of communications and reporting in Germany in 1945 makes getting an accurate number near impossible. What happened to the millions of guns and thousands of German tanks from the Third Reich? Only 3 years after the end of WWII, it seems to me that European countries like France, Belgium and the Netherlands, that had been occupied by the Nazis during the war, suddenly forgave and forgot about all that. On Point. It crippled Germany’s economy through war reparations which led the German government to print money. Reply reply More repliesMore replies Germany was the strongest power of the Central Powers and the main opponent of the western Entent, combine this with WW2, which we started, and the fact that germany is also partially at fault for (the escalation of) ww1 and you can see why the misconception that germany started ww1 is popular. They knew about the camps and all the other atrocities committed by the Nazis (which is not to say that there were completely clean themselves), but still they moved on to sign You're going to go by the strongest army in world war II universally its the United States. For instance, Belgium received An interesting chain of thought arising from another discussion: why is it that the Imperial German Army does so well in WW1 while the Wehrmacht does so poorly in WW2? This question requires a bit of explanation, as arguably the Wehrmacht accomplished more in France than the Imperial Germany Army did. As per usual, happy to answer any questions and grateful for good feedback. People in Germany felt treated unfairly and resented countries like France and England for it. What if Germany was split in two as in the original time with an allied controlled west and a Soviet controlled East. I obviously knew Hitler and the Nazis were terrible humans - but I never fully grasped just how evil they were until watching the docuseries. Other than that, pretty good. 7K votes, 873 comments. What if after WW1, South Germany and Austria formed a state? How that would affect WW2, if it still happens? This is important because in the post-war era of Germany this gave the western Allies some "plausible deniability" when it came to employing and using Germans to rebuild and rearm West Germany. 1 Gunner is in WW1 and every picture has the No. Russia is vast, and so are her resources. That's simply not true at all. After they lost WW1 how did they recover well enough to fight WW2 against the rest of Europe? And now after losing 2 world wars, how did they recover to become a dominant economy on modern times? the country only really existed since 1871 when the german empire formed, all the way up to ww2 german unification was an issue. 149K subscribers in the ww2 community. , Britain and France to European peace and stability? Share Add a Comment Sort by: Best Open comment sort options Top New Controversial Old Q&A [deleted] • After the wall fell, East Germany was basically absorbed into West Germany to become Germany. The Allies, naturally, were bound by the Potsdam Agreement. In actuality Germany did not get much by way of food from the east, instead it was their occupation of major agricultural countries in the west and North (eg. Puttees also came in many different fabrics and colours - oft not matching the uniform at all. After world War 1 (yes, WW1) ended, Germany was forced to give some of its territory as a compensation to neighboring countries it had attacked. Thanks List of webbing equipment There are many present and past designs of webbing equipment – load-carrying aids mainly of military application. I'd say focusing on supporting the different ethnicities in Russia so they rise and also a focus on the eastern front in general. Also, things like radar and communications networks improved - for example look at the chain home system that Britain used to detect inbound attackers. Japan takes the west/pacific and Germany gets the east/atlantic. A war that is more of a candidate for being forgotten is the Korean War, unfortunately. A communist Germany would have resulted in a Russo-German alliance and a communist victory in World War II. trueI find it impressive how after losing 2 world wars Germany's economy was still able to be really strong. Thank you for responding. Is there any truth to this, and if so was it in any way a major thing, or a rare occurrence that has been lionized suring the Cold War? The UK wanted to reclaim Ireland entirely (Ulster initially) because of the loss at WW1 making the populace more supportive of "glory-restoring acts" (basicalky imperialism) so Ireland had no choice but to seek German protection. there were alot of people older than germany alive in WW2. Here's a picture depicting those changes. If you're a Nazi though, fuck off. My Growing East German Field Uniform (Webbing incomplete) 1 / 4 0 comments Best Add a Comment That wasn't true about battle of Stalingrad but it was more than common occurrence in WW1. 1 Gunner in WW2 and these photos are mostly from 1941 before the Japanese invasion of Malaya. 2) Attacking Russia, aka "the worst strategic decision in history" (cf. Conquer Britain and then start on the Eastern Front after re-mobilising themselves? Or invade Russia and then start on the western front . [More info and images in the comments] German Add a Comment Sort by: I hate to say this because I don’t want it to start any w**** s*premacy arguements but why was the German army able to give Britain and France a run for their money in WW1, WW2, and after the west German army was allowed to rearm considered one of the best militaries in Europe. ack abxba njer ryru nmmqcy zzqz zuhtkl smllk jcsskf lrbw