Rock climbing vs mountain climbing height reddit. Edit: thanks for all the great advice!! I was just feeling a little discouaged because I can easily do the 10a routes at our gym but every 10b I try it Reddit's rock climbing training community. Cordless and proud. You often see this in both comp climbing and it has been shown before on pro climber vids where they wear one of each shoe depending on if they need stiff or soft. Feb 23, 2020 · Height is often viewed as an advantage in rock climbing, but is that really the case? We take a look and show it's not quite as clear cut as you may think. As said before mountain project has some really good info on some of these but Gannet and Granite haven't been reported or writen about as in depth due to their remoteness. Over time your mind will adjust. 331 votes, 144 comments. Bouldering was seen as simply training for rock climbing. Climbing helmets protect primarily from falling objects, usually but not exclusively rockfall, so if there is a person on the wall, animals in the area or loose rock, the helmet doesn't come off, even if we're taking a break, unless we move away from the wall. As you said, there are pros and cons on both ends of the height spectrum. [2] Rock climbing tends to require more stamina and works the legs, while bouldering Climbing the highest peak requires intense physical activity inside a low oxygen environment, while looking out for all kinds of dangers like avalanches, rock falls, ice and blizzard conditions. The key difference lies in the height of the climb and the equipment used 24 votes, 86 comments. My local gym charges $25 for a day pass and $85/month for a monthly membership. Short climbers: how do you deal with this technique wise? Maybe there are some routes that I'm just not going to be able to do do. I have the impression that body tension is a huge factor for climbing better as a tall person. Soft shoes for high end bouldering? Both. As a person climbing there every week, I can say about 65% of the student climbers are white, 30% Asian, less than 5% are other ethnic groups. What parts of rock climbing translate well to tree climbing, and what parts of tree climbing are completely different? I’ve got a mountain hardware “multipitch 30L” and it’s definitely as big as I would want to go for any pack I’m gonna actually wear climbing. The highest grade I completed was a 5. Oct 6, 2022 · In the world of adventure, rock climbing and mountaineering seem to have a lot of overlap. Get insights on differences, necessary skills, gear, and how to choose. Climbing definitely motivated me to drop weight. Oct 17, 2022 · Does being tall really make you a better climber? We ask the professionals to weigh in on this age-old climbing rumor Mountain climbing vs rock climbing is a challenging sport with physical and mental strength, technical skills, and the right tools. Less gear, faster pace. 256 votes, 75 comments. Exposure is being in a high place with nothing around you. 167K subscribers in the climbharder community. MembersOnline • _spacemonster ADMIN MOD Bouldering is what most of us would call Rock Climbing, AKA climbing vertical walls, usually with ropes and carabiners and such unless you're Alex Honnold. MembersOnline • crimpy_thang ADMIN MOD 360 votes, 76 comments. A Google search sums it up pretty well in my opinion. I'm not that shocked a guy as strong as Magnus can beat a strongman in this type of grip strength challenge. Keep in mind that it takes more effort for a taller person to build up enough body tension, which is one reason why gymnasts today tend to be shorter. trail running vs. If you think of everest as a common example, large group of mountain climbers in an expedition hauling gear between camps vs 2-3 professional alpinists trying a new route carrying only the gear they need to summit. MembersOnline • Professional_Sea2509 ADMIN MOD 1. Im terrible. So, what’s the difference between mountaineering and rock climbing? Rock climbing is a specific activity centered around vertical cliffs, while mountaineering is a more holistic sport focused on summiting mountains. After my first long multipitch route (on the wall about five hours) I was effectively cured of sensitivity to exposure Everest is the highest mountain in the world. Route climbing demands you to move efficiently through the easy bits with efficient technique to allow as much energy as possible for the crux sections. Cornell also offers a women’s basic rock climbing course and a basic rock climbing course, and the cost is about the same for every course. To a first approximation, every climbing nation set up their own system. Reddit's rock climbing training community. So, my personal impression is that how the altitude affects your performance depends a lot on whether your performance is being limited by your endurance/aerobic capacity versus e. A better breakdown would be: Snow climbing Ice climbing Rock climbing Mixed climbing (two or more of the above three on the same route) The term ‘alpine-style’ was introduced in contrast to ‘expedition-style’ to describe fast ascents of mountains without relying heavily on fixed ropes or seige tactics, and generally not using oxygen. Stiff vs. Curious about the distinction between rock climbing vs bouldering? Both activities involve scaling vertical surfaces, but here’s the kicker: rock climbing typically involves taller cliffs with harnesses and ropes for safety, whereas bouldering is done on shorter walls without harnesses, relying solely on crash pads. Nov 30, 2024 · Discover the differences between bouldering and rock climbing, including height, equipment, and grading systems. ) "Mountain climber" could be anything. Compared to the gym I liked it much more cause the progression sounded more like a game and it developed a lot a mind/body connection and consciousness (like yoga). Alex Honnold is the best in the world, and the best of all time, in the particular niche of climbing he has chosen to specialise in, namely free soloing big walls. Me as a roadie living in a valley surrounded by mountain ranges, I live for the long steep climbs and fast descents (though the road feels like rough gravel at times with all the potholes). So on an arete above the treetops or on top of a pinnacle versus on a thirty foot face route under the trees. [1] Bouldering is a form of rock climbing that involves lower walls and more technical movements, and is done without ropes or harnesses. I have a feeling that improving all of these things could be very helpful in mountaineering, especially in higher mountains. ELI5: when rock climbing how do climbers get their hook/anchor above them to climb up? Why isn’t there more info about people climbing the steepest, tallest face in the world, Mt Thor? Reddit's rock climbing training community. The analysis shows the most important factor in getting better at outdoor rock climbing is going climbing outside (crazy!), followed by several varieties of finger strength and upper-body strength. Jul 11, 2023 · Discover the difference between rock climbing and mountaineering. hiking vs. Feb 26, 2025 · Key Elements of Rock Climbing: Height and Length: Rock climbing typically involves long, multi-pitch climbs, meaning you ascend multiple sections of a cliff or wall. skiing. I’ve also included which climbers achieved Gold, Silver, and Bronze medals in the combined disciplines. If you climb anything under V6 being tall is almost always more advantageous. Read on for a more in-depth analysis on whether or not there’s a correlation between height and rock climbing skill! Climbing helmets are more geared to something hitting you, like a falling rock. There's a climber called Yves Gravelle (65 kilos) who also trains specifically for grip challenges and has lifted the inch dumbell and has reached the podium in comps where he's severely out sized. Dec 8, 2022 · Ultimately, however, the short answer is that whatever type of climbing you’re interested in trying, you shouldn’t let your height be a deciding factor. And yes we are scared of falling. And if I plan a more flat or or mainly up and down activity I choose hiking. Although both involve increasing slope elevation, there is a notable difference between the two. People here are always asking about climbing pants so I thought I’d do a review of all my favorites! I have about 5 years of rock climbing experience and have done a handful of easy alpine multi pitch climbs. However, if you were part of I started climbing when I was overweight, not obese— 167 lbs (F/26/5’9”) and I dropped down as low to 130-135 agger about 1 year of being seriously into climbing. At first glance, it seems that being taller is a handicap in rock climbing see here for a reddit discussion or my own analysis here. Essentially the same skills but different disciplines, alpinism is considered the more 'pure form'. If you start climbing and comparing different mountains based on their elevation above sea level, then there is good reason to climb Everest. 310 votes, 177 comments. The problem, then, is when you want to talk about near vertical surfaces. Explore the thrill of scaling cliffs or conquering majestic peaks in this guide. 1. Also, climbing mountains is fucking awesome. So, for this article, rock climbing refers to free climbing with ropes and equipment used to protect a falling climber from injury. MembersOnline • thinkingwithfractals Jun 1, 2023 · Height in Bouldering: Advantages and Challenges. 410K subscribers in the bouldering community. So your coordinate system for that starts at flat ground going away from you (0deg) and increases as things get more vertical. Bouldering, the exhilarating sport of scaling rock formations without ropes, requires strength, technique, and agility. The training, the planning, the gear, and the technical skills needed to succeed take years to obtain but the rewards make it all worth it. In terms of height advantage, I'd say it depends on the grade you climb. The fact that taller people also weight more (in absolute terms) seems to cause this negative correlation between height and weight. I’m curious if any people in this group started out rock climbing before getting into tree climbing. And im 5'10" if that matters Reply reply More replies difmaster • Reddit's rock climbing training community. MembersOnline • SirBam ADMIN MOD None of the mountaineering courses require climbing experience, and they do not teach rock climbing. Climbing shoes have wildly differing shapes. . Your body is only so adaptable, and at the high end of performance small adaptations away from climbing toward swimming will reduce your overall results at both. While both involve scaling vertical surfaces, they differ in terms of equipment, techniques, and overall approach. Oh its definitely technique. I really like calisthenics and I used it this past two years to get strong. Jul 13, 2016 · Written by Abree Murch of EVO Concord A frequently asked question among humans who are unfamiliar (or new) to climbing, might be: “What’s the difference between “free climbing” and “free soloing?” The mainstream media struggled hard with this during the coverage of Tommy Caldwell and Kevin Jorgeson’s Dawn Wall ascent, and most climbing gym staff will tell you that if they had a In my 25ish years of owning well over a dozen mountain bikes of various types, I've found that strong legs and cardiovascular health are the biggest contributors to a bike's climbing performance. muscular power, balance, or technique. And fit is the most important thing about climbing shoes. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. For example the front lever is significantly Reddit's rock climbing training community. 53 votes, 93 comments. I think just about everybody would call that an 85deg slope. 6. 3K votes, 260 comments. I look like a flailing cat trying to muscle his way up the mountain. At that time I had been climbing for maybe 15 years already and was working at my local gym. The home of Climbing on reddit. Im not naturally athletic, plus years of competitive weightlifting - for me at least - does not translate in any way to rock climbing. I've recently gotten into rock climbing and was wondering if it's an effective way to get a calisthenic workout?… Reddit's rock climbing training community. A subreddit for the indoor bouldering community. MembersOnline • Twonkular ADMIN MOD When you feel comfortable with classic mountaineering you can start rock climbing in order to train for more technical summits, usually the ones involving long glaciated approaches and several pitches of ice climbing like Puntiagudo or Corcovado. Was ridiculously strong back then, until inflation hit and I was forced to abandon driving 50 miles from work just to go to the rock climbing gym. If it is completely flat I will choose walking. Holds a full double rack + whatever stuff, bucket design with gear loops inside (and some zip pockets), rope on top. A good rule of thumb is in any given grade at any given rock, style, and steepness (sandstone splitters vs granite friction slab) climb a mile in the style at that grade. This makes purely climbing a terrible stand-in for weight training. Hey y'all. Trad climbing up the ante a bit, again for multipitch or adventure climbing, again for ice and alpine climbing, and again for serious big mountain alpine climbing. I need a little advice on balancing everything. This one is different than the Hike and Climb activities, as it's designed specifically for slow-moving vertical (or near-vertical) climbs. Mar 14, 2023 · Tl;dr: This analysis shows that weight, gender, height, and ape index do not play a significant role in a person’s maximum sport climbing grade or bouldering grade. Desensitization. Specifically lead and bouldering is there anyone who does both consistently. I have been bouldering for the last two months and just started completing a few v3s, although mostly a v2 climber. However, there's one One of my friends was killed by an avalanche on Mount Rainier, it was his sixth time climbing the mountain but first via that route. Sep 6, 2022 · The only noticeable difference between short and tall climbers is that the weaknesses of a shorter climber are more prevalent in the early stages of rock climbing while the defections of tall climbers show in later stages of climbing. 4M subscribers in the climbing community. What mountaineer wouldn't want to climb the highest mountain in the world? Reddit's rock climbing training community. Apr 10, 2022 · When most non-climbers picture rock climbing, they imagine people using ropes and other gear to climb tall cliff faces or mountain summits. From advice on which gym to visit to videos of world cup IFSC climbers, you can find it all here. However, that's not where most climbers are so it seems like a little bit of a red herring to talk about it that way. Never use one in the gym as there is no danger of rock fall. Dedicated to increasing all our… You do not need upper body strength to start climbing! Climbing involves your legs and core a lot more than you would think. Will there come a day when men and women competing on the same routes becomes the norm? Sure men are Reddit's rock climbing training community. How Tall Are Women’s Olympic Climbers? The average height of the female climbers mentioned below was just over 5 feet 4 inches. Most routes on Gannett have significantly less rock and technical climbing than the grand even the more difficult lines. General Question: in terms of physical fitness is mountaineering more akin to rock climbing or trail running? Especially outdoor communities like climbing, mountain biking, snowboarding etc. I have my own gym at home, but it is not the same. Uncover the impact of height on climbing performance and the diverse experiences of tall and short climbers. MembersOnline • HarryCaul ADMIN MOD Not sure if it was mistyped, but nothing in climbing is "safe," as a climbing gym employee we literally are told not to tell people something is safe because there is ALWAYS a risk for injury. 3M subscribers in the climbing community. So the "altitude that makes a difference" will be different for rock climbing vs. What helmets do people recommend for year round usage, from summer climbing to winter mountaineering and climbing? Reddit's rock climbing training community. However, as things reopened after COVID I really wanted to do a sport to get involved with people and create a real community and group you can hang out If your goals involve rock climbing, spend time rock climbing. Have a pair of each for what you need and when you need it. Nov 4, 2024 · Rock climbing requires more power endurance since you’re climbing longer routes, often 20-30 meters high. Ive only been top rope climbing at the gym twice and didnt go for any hard routes, just wanted to get comfortable being higher up on the wall and got too tired before trying to go up the grades. Skiing helmets are more to protect your head when you hit something and distribute and absorb the force of impact, like hitting a tree. Once you progress in your climbing, that's where I'd spent my time with supplemental exercises to work on getting stronger for climbing. The best height for male rock climbers is 5’9, and the best height for female rock climbers is 5’4, based upon the average height of the climbers competing in the 2021 Olympics. Dedicated to increasing all our knowledge about how to better improve at our sport. I’ve taken a break from bjj due to college and I’m coming back to it, in the meantime I’ve picked up rock climbing. I see some intersections between rock climbing and mountaineering. (crosspost with r/CompetitionClimbing and r/climbing ) I was interested in the height data of the best climbers in the world… Climber = rock climbing (no snow/ice) Alpinist = rock/ice/snow climbing, requiring a large range of skills (scrambling, ice climbing, aid climbing, rock climbing, glacier travel, camping, etc. Any tips for outdoor climbing? Im pretty I personally choose the climb activity if I go mainly upwards in a mountain area so if I plan to go to a summit. There are two things to consider: height and exposure. Essentially, rock climbing is a more specific sport than mountaineering. For example, in some competitions (bouldering World Cup) women have been given problems in the final that were semi-final problems for the men, and the women sent the problems that many guys couldn't. I still can't do a pull-up after 5 years of climbing. Because lots of different factors come into play when assessing the difficulty of a given climb, and different systems consider different things, it's not always straightforward to convert between systems. Jun 21, 2025 · Rock climbing is a broad category of sports that involve using your hands and feet to ascend a wall or rock face, and often requires safety equipment like ropes and anchors. Although even in the niche others have achieved things nearly as impressive, for example Hans-Jörg Auer's solo of The Fish in the Dolomites, on a similar scale to Freerider, only slightly easier, and done with much less prior Mar 15, 2024 · Bouldering vs. 23 votes, 70 comments. Still images and videos of both activities show fearless explorers tackling mountains wearing harnesses and using ropes, but are these two pursuits actually the same thing? We take a look at the similarities and differences between mountaineering vs rock climbing to help you understand the finer details Is very frustrating to watch friends who are taller than me easily reach holds that are just out of reach for me. So although you'd probably be better at super technical individual moves, bouldering doesn't make you better at flowing through easy bits without losing much stamina. MembersOnline • Dino_smore ADMIN MOD Bouldering vs rock climbing… what really are the differences you need to know about? We explain it here. Bouldering and lead climbing focus on different aspects – bouldering emphasizes explosive power for short, intense problems, while climbing demands sustained endurance and mental focus. g. As far as loose chalk goes, all good climbing chalk is pretty much pure magnesium carbonate so no real difference there - what does vary a lot is texture, anything from fine powder to large chunks. This means that as soon as you start talking about overhangs This made me think about mountaineering in general. Rock Climbing: These are two distinct yet closely related disciplines within the world of climbing. Explore the thrilling world of mountain climbing vs rock climbing. Everything else is really Realistic: If you're a super high performer at climbing, doing activity that isn't climbing is going to take away from that. I think rock climbing helped me notice some lack of my balance, weak legs, or even foot placement. You could say if the Fokus is on height I choose climbing and if the focus is more on length I choose hiking. For the shorter climber, strength counts more. Honestly most real world communities are just really chill and welcoming. May 30, 2023 · Essentially, taller climbers are good because of their height, while shorter climbers are good because they are stronger and, perhaps, technically better. Unfortunately climbing can be pretty expensive. Some climbs can take several hours or even days to complete. The taller you are, the more body tension you need on moves that are easy for smaller climbers. Like, say, one that is not overhung, and less than vertical by 5deg. Anything related to indoor (and outdoor) goes. Super insanely durable, the thing is made of ridiculously strong thick material. I have taken a fresh look at this relationship. Mountaineering: pick 2 or 3 - walking, climbing, snow/ice skills Hiking San Gorgonio via the Vivian Creek Trail in the summer, for example, is not mountaineering because it's all trail. I'm 6'3". Finger strength rules everything in climbing, and that's just never hit correctly in regular weight training. So go to a shop, try on as may shoes as you can and buy the one that fits your feet best. 71 votes, 109 comments. Some of them teach pitched climbing on snow and ice, short pitching and roping on rock, and general rock and rope skills, but nowhere does it seem like climbing is necessary. If we go by height of climbers at the elite level, yes, being tall seems to be more of a liability than being short. trueThe gap in grade between women and men gets narrower all the time. but also weight lifting, body building, martial arts etc. I hate that rope climbing is called “rock climbing” while bouldering is separate, but that’s how it was pre-1980’s. MembersOnline • IntelligentSun590 Honestly I thought mountain bikers hated climbing and only wanted to go downhill (hence the lifts and eMTBs on dedicated MTB parks). iivzx aagho iypip xrmcw apph awgv blovzs pmq nlese ykow